Fresh salsa with tomatoes is one of the fastest, best-tasting ways to use ripe summer tomatoes without turning on the oven — the recipe is less about strict proportions and more about balance: juicy tomatoes, a little sharpness, a little heat, and enough salt to bring everything together.
Condiment
Easy
Mexican
Fresh salsa with tomatoes
One of the fastest, best-tasting ways to use ripe summer tomatoes without turning on the oven — ripe tomatoes, a little sharpness, a little heat, and enough salt to bring it together.
- Time
- 15 min
- Serves
- 4 to 6
Fresh salsa with tomatoes
Makes About 2 cups
Ingredients (6)
Instructions
0 of 5
Nutrition
Estimated per serving · 1/3 cup
25
Calories
1 g
Protein
5 g
Carbs
0 g
Fat
1 g
Fiber
3 g
Sugar
100 mg
Sodium
What to look for when you shop
Best varieties
- Roma / plum — dense and less watery, ideal for a thick salsa
- Early Girl — tart, good balance of acid and sweetness year-round
- Cherry tomatoes — sweet, consistent, no seeding needed
- Heirloom slicers — complex flavor, wetter; drain briefly before mixing
Ripeness
Yields slightly to gentle pressure; deeply colored all the way to the stem; fragrant. Under-ripe tomatoes give a flat, starchy salsa with no amount of lime fixing it.
Imperfections are fine
Cracked, blemished, or irregular tomatoes from a farm often have more concentrated flavor than perfect-looking supermarket fruit. Trim any soft spots and dice what remains.
Good substitutions
- Tomatillos for salsa verde — roast or use raw for different profiles
- Roasted tomatoes for a deeper, smoky salsa
- Diced mango to replace 1/3 of the tomatoes for a sweet-tart riff
In season
Peak July through September in most US regions. This recipe is worth making only with in-season tomatoes — it does not recover from bland fruit.
How much to buy
About 1 lb of tomatoes (4–5 medium) makes roughly 2 cups of finished salsa.
From a grower near you
Find your tomato grower on CollectiveCrop
Salsa is barely a recipe — it's chopped tomatoes, chopped aromatics, lime, salt. The tomato is 80% of what you're tasting. A supermarket tomato bred for shipping gives you watery, flat salsa no matter how much cilantro and jalapeño you add. CollectiveCrop is how the local grower with actual tomatoes becomes findable. Make this in August with their crop, and it's a different food.
- In season July through September
- For this recipe 1 lb / about 4–5 medium tomatoes
- While you're there Fresh jalapeños · Cilantro · White onion · Limes
At the market
About 1 lb of tomatoes (4–5 medium) makes roughly 2 cups of finished salsa.
Best varieties
- Roma / plum dense and less watery, ideal for a thick salsa
- Early Girl tart, good balance of acid and sweetness year-round
- Cherry tomatoes sweet, consistent, no seeding needed
Good to know
Tips
- The quality of the tomatoes is the single most important factor — use the ripest you can find.
- Removing the seeds and watery core gives a thicker salsa that does not immediately pool on the chip.
- The heat level depends entirely on the chile — start with half and taste before adding the rest.
Storage
- Refrigerator: up to 3 days; the salsa is brightest and freshest on day 1.
- Drain any accumulated liquid before serving leftovers.
- Freezer: not recommended — tomatoes lose their fresh texture completely.
Make ahead
- Dice the tomatoes and onion up to 1 hour ahead; hold separately in the fridge.
- Mix the salsa up to 30 minutes before serving to let flavors meld without losing brightness.
- Add fresh herbs only right before serving.
Variations
- Mango salsa: replace 1/3 of the tomatoes with diced ripe mango.
- Roasted salsa: char the tomatoes and jalapeños under the broiler or on a grill first.
- Salsa verde: substitute tomatillos for the tomatoes and roast before blending.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you make fresh salsa with tomatoes ahead of time?
You can chop the ingredients ahead, but salsa is brightest shortly after mixing.
What can you serve with fresh salsa with tomatoes?
Serve it with tacos, grilled food, eggs, chips, beans, or grain bowls.
Can you swap one of the main ingredients?
Yes. Different tomato types, onion types, and herbs can all work as long as the salsa stays balanced.
More recipes to try
See every recipe →
Know what's worth cooking this week
Get one recipe a week — always timed to what's actually in season near you. No filler, no fluff.